Dear Friend,
For this blog, I want to focus a little bit about exercising vs diet, and what each contribute to this overarching goal of “good health.” I hope you enjoy!
A Quick Couple Paragraphs on Diet~
Most people start a diet because they want we do to lose weight.
And generally, when it comes to weight loss, we tend to think of a combination of diet and exercises (or if you really want to think about your body like a machine, calories in and calories out).
Calories in-calories out is simplified view, but like it or not, a pretty accurate way the body works. There are some nuances of course: how efficient your body is in storing those calories varies from person to person (which is basically our genetics, and perhaps even epigenetics…another blog by another person for sure).
(But in case you’re interested… epigenetics is the study of what happens around (epi) a person's DNA (genetics). It's how an environment and environmental conditions can affect a person's DNA. These are typically in the form of a methyl molecule on a strand of DNA (called methylation), that either inhibits or allows expression of the gene in the person. This can be passed down genetically to one's offspring, so it's a pretty cool but important deal. There have been studies on individuals who have survived famine, had descendants, who then will hold onto nutrients more stubbornly to protect against a possible environment where food is scarce. You’re welcome.)
Okay back to it. Calories in, calories out. Genetics. We can talk more about macronutrients another time. Or never--I'm not a nutritionist, but yes there is more to this if we want to dive into the nuance. But quickly: balanced diet is always preferred because you need to fuel well, and you need the essential minerals and amino acids to run your body well.
And also, whether we want to gain or lose weight, how we eat is a good place to focus.
I mean like…almost entirely.
How about Exercise?
Okay let's say you're new to exercise. You've never went hard with it before. You're young, you're ready, you join a run club that does some solid weight-based cross-training. And because you love it so much, and you made some friends, you actually start to go regularly. Before you know it, you notice that you dropped quite a few pounds in a short amount of time.
Pretty cool, right!?
As you continue to train, however, your weight starts to plateau. No more changes to the waist band... “Dang!” you think to yourself. “If I could lose just 5 more pounds, I'd be at my ideal weight!”
Why does the body do this? Doesn't calories in and calories out work here too (exercise= calories out, no?)
It still does! But here are a couple of thoughts. Firstly, beginner effects in exercise is VERY real. When you shock your body by doing a new thing really quickly and intensely, you will notice a change (here is you official sign to get started if you haven't already. Get. Them. Gains).
Then eventually, the body seeks to find allostasis: harmony with what the new environment is presenting. Once your body recognizes these new environmental demands (regular exercise), it starts to make adjustments. After all, you can't keep going to whither away to nothing. Your body needs to manage these new stressors and start to put some aspects into place so that you can be efficient with your calorie consumption and expenditure.
In fact, you'll also notice you'll need to eat more to keep up with this new pace.
And even if we keep the calories-in portion the same, your body will find sneaky ways for you to manage your energy better. Less fidgeting, less talking, things that, over time, do contribute to your calories-out basket (look up NEAT to learn more). Worse still, your performance and capacity at work or during run club could diminish…eat the nutrients ya need, kids.
So…in short. Exercise is actually a lowsy way to lose weight. So why do we do it?
You Were Built to Move!
I used to joke with my roommate last year about my likeness to a border collie. I told her that I need to be fricking doing things- whether work related, exercise related or creating something or I'd make up problems for myself and cause a havoc.
Maybe you feel the same, or maybe you don't, but actually, it's quite helpful to think of ourselves like other animals in that we need to run around and let off some steam. We need our muscles to move and our hearts to pump because, for millennia, we were build to use up that energy we consume. When we live a more sedentary life, our body turns that energy inwards to different systems in the body. From a simplified point of view, you can think of this as inflammation.
Inflammation is a common cause for all sorts of ailments, and when you think about what inflammation really is, it's your immune system on overdrive, attacking and working against the body itself. When you don't move enough, adipose tissue starts to build up around the organs (this is specifically called visceral fat). The build up of visceral fat acts like an organ in of itself, and promotes certain pro-inflammatory hormones to be sent to the rest of the body, essentially getting the body to work on overdrive. These can contribute to varying diseases linked to inflammation including many different types of cancers, cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, osteoporosis and so many more.
And of course another note, when muscles aren't being used, they start to whither away and atrophy…and you quite literally need those muscles to move, to pump blood, to live. Muscles have a general protective effect against the natural decline that comes with aging, but they also produce hormones that have a protective effect in regulating inflammation, along with regulating stress hormones like cortisol (sometimes a good hormone to have, but chronic cortisol succkkksss).
Our Modern Era Sucks for Managing this kind of Health
The most obvious thing to say here is that we must have a good balance of both healthy food, and physical activity (and do our best to have good community, manage infectious diseases, avoid environmental toxins etc.) to live a good and healthy life. Try to avoid the things tryna kill you--both in the excess and lack of things.
But that shits hard. In our attempt to live a good life, I think we can go overboard and become obsessive; body dysmorphia, eating disorders, over-exercising to name a few examples. However in our quest for greater health, we do need to acknowledge that going along with the way things are day to day, is NOT going to land us in good health. I wish we lived in a society that prioritized healthy sleeping patterns, nutritious and affordable foods, and work days that didn't leave one so beat and tired to exercise afterwards. But we don't. We have a society that's just enough to keep this industrious economic monster trudging along.
If you're reading these blogs, I know you're someone who cares about their health. I know you're curious, and interested, and maybe wanting to stay inspired. I say these things about our current system because they're true, yes, but because nobody is going to MAKE you do the healthy things, we're not in school anymore. We need to recognize how our choices everyday make up the lives we want to live. No, it's not easy, but I personally try my hardest to make these options as readily available and simple to the patients and clients I work with. And without sounding like I'm on a fricken soap box, just a small reminder…
Don't undercut your health. Don't ignore your body. You only get one of those…and it's an important part of being able to live a joyous and wonderous life. I love movement, but sometimes I really fricken don't. But I'm happy I've worked hard to get to the point where it's a non-negotiable in my life, and I hope my efforts will in turn, continue to work to take care of me as I age.
Okay, soapbox moment over. Thanks.
This topic really helped me recontextualize the importance of movement. When we take the idea of “using” exercise as a way to get fitter, it can sound a bit vain…but when we think about how we literally NEED it as part of taking care of our body, can help flip the salience switch in many people's minds.
References:
1. Fiuza-Luces, C., Santos-Lozano, A., Joyner, M., Carrera-Bastos, P., Picazo, O., Zugaza, J. L., Izquierdo, M., Ruilope, L. M., & Lucia, A. (2018). Exercise benefits in cardiovascular disease: beyond attenuation of traditional risk factors. Nature reviews. Cardiology, 15(12), 731–743. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41569-018-0065-1
2. Furman, D., Campisi, J., Verdin, E. et al. Chronic inflammation in the etiology of disease across the life span. Nat Med 25, 1822–1832 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-019-0675-0
3. Silverman, M. N., & Deuster, P. A. (2014). Biological mechanisms underlying the role of physical fitness in health and resilience. Interface focus, 4(5), 20140040. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsfs.2014.0040